Skip to main content

Book Discussion: Rumble


Okay, maybe I'm cheating a bit because this "discussion" is not actually a real discussion. It's just a record of my imaginary discussion with some people who wrote about Rumble on Goodreads.

I had originally went to Goodreads to look at some other reviews of Rumble. While I was there, I happened to stumble upon the comments, where I was surprised with some people's thoughts on the book. Many of them had lots to say on the book's topics, such as depression/suicide, the LGBT+ community, anxiety, family issues, religion, and so forth. And while I do not have a Goodreads account, I still have a lot to say myself. So, without further ado, I shall begin.

Note: the dialogue below are not actual quotes. They are just lines that I wrote that show a general thought by some readers of Rumble. Also, this post contains spoilers. If you would like to read my book review on Rumble instead, click here.


"Why did Hopkins write her book in free verse?? Like, seriously...it doesn't serve any significant purpose! Also, it doesn't make sense. Too difficult to comprehend & pointless!" 
First of all, I would like to apologize if I made that sound too whiny. Moving on, I do not agree with this viewpoint. An author would not simply write a book in free verse for no reason. The structure and word choice of the poems that make up the book have probably been selected carefully by the author. While I do have to agree that this is not the best example of free verse in novels that I have seen, it is still alright. And I do not believe that it is too difficult to understand, as long as you look at it properly.


"Hopkins ended the book with, 'Because if there's one thing I've learned through all of this, it's to have faith in love.' I did not like this. Where did that come from? What about everything else?"
Okay, I have to say that I agree with this one. This really was not what I was expecting. What about the whole forgiving thing? Is that not important enough to put at the end? I suppose I kinda see how the love fits in with forgiveness, but I don't think that this theme was very strong throughout the book. More towards the end, I would say. Overall, I believe that there were some more important ideas/themes to end with...

"Why does the book discuss religion so much? I hate it! In the book, Matt hardly cares for any type of religion and the Christians shown in the book are portrayed as really rude! Ellen Hopkins shouldn't do that, and should be respectful towards all religions."
I actually like how Hopkins took the chance and wrote so openly about religion. After all, religion is something debated on and can actually cause a lot of conflict in the world. Also, so what if Matt isn't involved in religion? People can choose what they do and don't believe in. Yeah, maybe the Christians in the book are shown as rude. But this doesn't mean that all Christians are rude or homophobic. I'm sorry if this has hurt you, but, unfortunately, a good deal of people claim that being homosexual is wrong because the Bible says this. To add, just because the main character has these certain views towards religion, it doesn't mean that Hopkins is trying to say that all religion is wrong and that Christians are evil.

"Ew: the romance. More than I wanted."
Yeah...there was more romance than I wanted, too. But, hey: we have to accept that most teens will like romance in books. I am actually starting to believe that some authors include romance to make a book sell better...

"I hate Matt. I absolutely hate him. He's such a glass-half-empty sort of guy, and he's so judgy, too! And then he goes and whines about it? Ugh: how could anyone stand to read 500-something pages with him as the narrator?"
Okay, I hate to tell you this, but sometimes characters in books are going to be awful. I mean, every character has to have some sort of flaw. It just makes them more realistic. Also, the reason why Matt is "judgy" and "a glass-half-empty sort of guy" is because of what he has gone through. His life stinks, and hardly anything seems to go well for him, so wouldn't it be understandable if he's pessimistic? I'm not exactly sure where people are getting the "judgy" idea from, but perhaps it is because of his views towards those who were mean to him? Sure, he could be less "judgy", but that's something he'll learn and grow from.

"Such a rushed ending. Seriously?"
Yeah, that really was rushed. I think there was only about 30 pages left of the book once the climax came. Also, like I said in my book review of Rumble, Matt suddenly started to forgive and love himself and others because of one thing. I didn't like this because 1) it was very quick, and 2) it seemed a little unrealistic. Not everyone will learn to forgive themselves due to a big accident.

"I like the open-mind concept of the book."
I do too. This book did deal with a lot of open-mindedness, including having an open-mind on homosexuality, depression, divorce, love, etc.

Well, that ends my "little" book discussion on Rumble. Don't agree with me? Have more to say? Then feel free to leave a comment below!

[If anyone is still reading this, I would like to apologize for our inactivity on Instagram. We are going through something right now, and I, Julia, usually take care of most of the things, but this thing has been bothering me quite a bit, so I have not felt like staying active. My apologies.]

Comments

  1. Hope you liked the book! I don't like it when authors rush the ending of a book, either.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

We would like to hear from you! What did you think of this post? Do you have any suggestions? Then please leave a comment. (We allow anonymous comments too!)

This Month's Popular Posts

Quotes: Audacity

As some of you may know by looking at my posts on our social media page (@readingisinevitable on Instagram), I am currently reading Audacity by Melanie Crowder. It is a beautiful book written in free verse, and follows the life of Clara Lemlich, a female Jewish immigrant who came to America in the early 1900s. (For the full summary of the book, click here.) I absolutely love books written in free verse, or any type of poetry, in fact! This book is so lovely that I have decided to dedicate a whole post to some of my favorite quotes or parts! (Note: I am only on page 294, and there are 366 pages, not including the extra content at the end of my local library's copy.)

Book Review: Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe

Title: Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe
Author: Benjamin Alire Sáenz
Genre: Realistic Fiction, YA Fiction
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars ★★★★★
Reviewer: Julia

Dante can swim. Ari can't. Dante is articulate and self-assured. Ari has a hard time with words and suffers from self-doubt. Dante gets lost in poetry and art. Ari gets lost in thoughts of his older brother who is in prison. Dante is fair skinned. Ari's features are much darker. It seems that a boy like Dante, with his open and unique perspective on life, would be the last person to break down the walls that Ari has built around himself. 

But against all odds, when Ari and Dante meet, they develop a special bond that will teach them the most important truths of their lives, and help define the people they want to be. But there are big hurdles in their way, and only by believing in each other — and the power of their friendship — can Ari and Dante emerge stronger on the other side. the book's synopsis
Aris…

Dear Readers - I'm Taking a Break

Hi, everyone. I guess you've read the title by now, which means I've got some explaining to do. As you may or may not know, I've been writing on this blog for somewhere around a year and a half now. In the beginning, I was very involved. I hadn't had an active blog for a few years, and the whole thing felt new again. I started out by writing book reviews on books I had recently read, and from there had time to finish other books and write reviews on them. And things were going well in the beginning. Even though Em dropped out after a short bit of time, I still kept this blog going. 
And then something happened. 
I just... started getting busier. I had less time to write posts and I had less books to review as I started reading less. I started to take these unannounced breaks where I'd just disappear for a bit. During those times I wasn't even sure myself when I'd come back to blogging, but I'd always come back at some point. Usually I'd be bored on…

September 2017 Reflection

Happy Friday everyone! How was your September? Good, I hope? What about your October? Can you believe we're already in October, and that we're even approaching our first complete week of it...? It's now the sixth of October and the first Friday of the month, which means it's time for yet another monthly reflection, in which I pretty much just ramble on about what happened this month as well as what's to come. Oooo... be excited. (It's okay you do whatever you want to do!)

Looking Back Into September The Blog Blargh. Blargh blargh blargh. So, the blog. It didn't do horribly, but things could have been better. (At least it was better than the bookstagram, but I'll get to that in a bit, heh heh...) I had to switch over to my school posting schedule, even though I would have liked to try to keep up two posts a week for at least one more month. But, alas, school is just too much. I mean, I couldn't even handle posting once a week. That's right, I mi…