Skip to main content

Book Review: Cast of Criminals

Title: Cast of Criminals
Author: Franklin W. Dixon
Genre: Mystery
Rating: 2 out of 5
Reviewer: Julia

In this mystery novel, the Hardy brothers, Joe and Frank, are helping out with the local play when suspicious events begin to occur. The mysterious happenings involve Frank's girlfriend, Callie, and her stolen "costume" tiara. Despite the danger surrounding them, the play must go on, even if Callie's life is in danger. Hopefully she won't have the same fate as her character in the play...

I have read several books in the Nancy Drew series. In the back of the books, they always advertised other books in the series and in another series: The Hardy Boys series. I never thought of reading any of The Hardy Boys series books until Em got me #97 in the series: Cast of Criminals. (She has been getting me these books that our library is giving away. Cast of Criminals is one of them.)

You are probably wondering why I said that this book deserves a 2 out of 5. "Perhaps this is a mistake," you might say. I must tell you that, while it hurts me to give a book this low of a rating, it is no mistake and is entirely intentional. For one thing, I did not enjoy the writing style of the book. It did include some descriptions, but the author continued to use phrases such as "what-do-you-mean" to describe some actions rather than using adjectives and allowing readers to figure it out themselves.

Speaking of readers figuring things out on their own, I was able to "solve" the mystery early on. While I did not have the complete story, I had most of the idea down, and my theory was only strengthened as more clues were given in the book. I don't know about you, but solving the mystery much before it is solved by the characters in a book always makes mysteries less exciting for me. Especially when the detectives are confused and you find yourself shouting at them because you know the answer.

Furthermore, the author didn't make me really care about the characters in the book, which is especially bad when one might die. I also did not like the way the author ended the book. It was a little silly, if you ask me.

Still, this book did accomplish one thing. It made me more interested in reading mysteries again. I can't believe that I forgot the fun of reading mystery novels. However, for my next mystery, I think I'll stick to Nancy Drew.



Looking for a better mystery? Then check out "Book Review: Wink Poppy Midnight".
"Wink Poppy Midnight is very interesting to read, and while you may think that you know what is going on in the book, trust me: you don't. There is more going on then you'll think.

This novel is told from three characters' points of views: Wink, Poppy, and Midnight. Wink is the girl who lives on the farm with her many siblings and mother, and believes in spirits and readings and doesn't care much about what others think. Poppy is the beautiful girl whom almost everyone--including herself--loves. However, she is "ugly on the inside". Midnight is the boy who moves across the street from Wink and is caught in the middle of it all. In the middle of what, you ask? Well..." Read more

Comments

  1. I can see why you gave the book only 2 out of 5 stars. Mysteries are no fun if you can figure it out too early in the book!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

We would like to hear from you! What did you think of this post? Do you have any suggestions? Then please leave a comment. (We allow anonymous comments too!)

This Month's Popular Posts

Quotes: The Nightingale

I realized that, over a year ago, I wrote a post called "Quotes: Audacity" , and that this post did really well (it's actually Reading is Inevitable's most read post!), and yet I never wrote another post of quotes from a book. I liked writing that post, too. I like sharing quotes I like from books. That's why I started doing it on our bookstagram page . So why did I never write another one of these "quote blog posts"? I don't know. But I intend to write at least another one. And that's why I'm here today. Well, there's that, and then there's also the amazing book that is The Nightingale.  If you've read some of my recent blog posts or have poked around a bit, you would know that exactly a month ago I published my book review on The Nightingale , in which I explained my love for it and why you should read it yourself. And while I actually have another post in the works on that book because it definitely deserves more than on...

How Quickly Can You Think of 100 Blog Post Ideas?

Here's a little situation that's very common for me: It's the day before a blog post is supposed to publish. (I have no blog post.) I think to myself, Oh, I have the whole day [afternoon, on school days] to come up with something and write it! No biggy! Soon it's past the afternoon: evening moving into night, and I still don't have a blog post done. I don't even have an idea. What's next? Why, the only thing I really can do: Panic. That's what happened this time, sad to say. (Whoops: I did it again!) I have a little list of blog post ideas that I have conjured up with hours of research spent on the internet, and as I was mentally going through the list, I recalled an idea that I had seen at  http://www.getspokal.com/i-challenged-myself-to-create-100-blog-post-ideas-in-30-minutes/ . In this little post, the writer - Sarah Burke - challenged herself to create 100 blog post ideas in only 30 minutes. I thought to myself, Hey! I have time since it...

August 2016 Reflection

Since the last day of August was this past Wednesday, that means that we are due for a monthly reflection! If you already know the drill, you can skip the following paragraph and move on, but if you don't know it or want a refresher, then go on a head. In these monthly reflections, I look back on the month for our blog, Reading is Inevitable, and our bookstagram (book + Instagram), @readingisinevitable . I also review the goals I had made the previous month. Then I write about what this month will be like for the blog and Instagram, as well as some goals for the upcoming month. The reason why I do these monthly reflections is so that I can see our growth and progress, and see what's working and what's not working. In these reflections, I make changes according to this. You, as a reader, can also see our growth, and get a sneak peek at what is to come. With that, I hope you enjoy this monthly reflection. I believe that August was a very good month for Reading is Inev...

Quotes: Audacity

As some of you may know by looking at my posts on our social media page (@readingisinevitable on Instagram), I am currently reading Audacity by Melanie Crowder. It is a beautiful book written in free verse, and follows the life of Clara Lemlich, a female Jewish immigrant who came to America in the early 1900s. (For the full summary of the book, click here .) I absolutely love books written in free verse, or any type of poetry, in fact! This book is so lovely that I have decided to dedicate a whole post to some of my favorite quotes or parts! (Note: I am only on page 294, and there are 366 pages, not including the extra content at the end of my local library's copy.)